When it comes to diamond clarity, VS1 and VS2 are two of the most popular grades. Both indicate very small inclusions that are difficult to see with the naked eye. So which is better – VS1 or VS2? There are a few key differences to consider when choosing between these two clarity grades.
What do VS1 and VS2 mean?
VS stands for “Very Slightly Included” and is the second highest clarity grade on the GIA diamond clarity scale. The scale ranges from Flawless (FL) to Included (I3) with 11 grades in between. Here’s a quick overview:
| Clarity Grade | Definition |
|---|---|
| VS1 | Very Slightly Included 1. Inclusions are difficult to locate and see under 10x magnification. |
| VS2 | Very Slightly Included 2. Inclusions are somewhat easy to locate and see under 10x magnification. |
As you can see, the main difference is that VS1 inclusions are more difficult to see than VS2 under 10x magnification. With the naked eye, VS1 and VS2 diamonds will appear identical with no visible inclusions. Only under magnification can a skilled jeweler detect the tiny flaws.
How much visible are the inclusions?
With VS1 diamonds, inclusions are extremely difficult to find, even for a trained eye. Only an expert gemologist will be able to see the tiny imperfections using a jeweler’s loupe or microscope. The inclusions are often tiny crystals scattered throughout the diamond.
For VS2 diamonds, the inclusions are more noticeable. They may appear as small flecks, clouds, or feathers inside the stone. The average person would still have trouble seeing them without magnification, but they are easier to detect for a jeweler. VS2 inclusions may be seen more readily with the naked eye if they are clustered together in an obvious way.
So in terms of visibility, VS1 inclusions are harder to see, resulting in a more eye-clean appearance. VS2 diamonds have minor inclusions that can more easily be spotted under 10x magnification.
How much do they impact durability?
Durability is also an important factor when comparing VS1 and VS2. In general, the fewer inclusions a diamond has, the more durable it will be. This is because flaws within the stone can potentially spread or widen over time, causing more noticeable problems down the road. Fractures or feathers on the surface make a diamond more prone to chipping and damage.
VS1 diamonds have extremely minor flaws that do not impact long-term durability in any significant way. The diamond remains just as strong and resistant to damage.
VS2 diamonds may have durability issues in some cases, depending on the number, size, type, and position of inclusions. If the flaws are numerous or clustered together in a weak area, the diamond is more likely to chip or crack. However, most VS2 diamonds will still be quite durable, nearly as much so as VS1. Only in more extreme cases would a VS2 potentially have compromised strength.
How much do they cost?
There is a price difference between VS1 and VS2 diamonds. VS1 commands a premium for that near flawless appearance. Prices for VS1 diamonds are approximately 10-20% more than VS2 diamonds of the same carat weight.
The exact price depends on the other factors like cut, color, and carat weight. But you can expect to pay around 10-20% more for a VS1 graded diamond compared to an equivalent VS2. In a 1 carat round diamond, that may equate to a $500 – $1000 difference.
The pricing gap does fluctuate and is not always consistent across retailers. But overall, VS1 diamonds trade at higher prices based on supply, demand, and the appeal of near flawless looks.
Examples of VS1 and VS2 Diamonds
Let’s compare some real-life examples of VS1 and VS2 diamonds so you can see the difference:
| Diamond | Details | Image |
|---|---|---|
| VS1 Round Diamond | 0.9 carat, G color |  |
| VS2 Oval Diamond | 1.5 carat, H color |  |
You can see the VS1 diamond has no visible inclusions, while the VS2 has a small feather toward the side that would likely be detected under magnification. Both are still beautiful diamonds that will appear clean to the naked eye.
Should I choose VS1 or VS2?
So should you go with a VS1 or VS2 diamond? Here are a few general guidelines:
– If your budget allows, VS1 is the safer choice. You get exceptional clarity and sparkle.
– If you want to maximize perceived quality for the price, lean toward VS1.
– If you want to save money, VS2 offers great value. In many cases VS2 is just as lovely.
– For diamonds over 1 carat, VS1 may be worth the extra cost. Larger VS2 stones often have more noticeable inclusions.
– For fancy shape diamonds like ovals, VS1 helps avoid visible inclusions in ends.
– If eye-clean appearance is everything, only accept VS2 diamonds with inclusions not visible to the naked eye.
No matter which grade you choose, always inspect the diamond closely rather than relying on the report alone. Work with an expert who can point out the inclusions and advise you on the best value. With some guidance, both VS1 and VS2 offer outstanding clarity at lower prices than higher grades like VVS or IF.
Pros and Cons Comparison
Here is a quick pro/con summary comparing VS1 and VS2 diamonds:
| VS1 | VS2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Visibility of Inclusions | Almost invisible | Minor inclusions visible under magnification |
| Durability | Excellent | Very good |
| Sparkle and Brilliance | Outstanding | Excellent |
| Price | 10-20% premium over VS2 | Better value |
| Overall Recommendation | Ideal for maximizing quality | Great option to save money |
As you can see, both offer tremendous value, sparkle, and almost no visible inclusions. VS1 is the top choice for a flawless appearance, while VS2 offers the best bang for your buck.
The Bottom Line
VS1 and VS2 diamonds are extremely similar and both make excellent choices. VS1 provides the best clarity and optics for those who can afford the premium price. For shoppers on a tighter budget, VS2 represents a great opportunity to save money while still getting a high quality diamond with stunning brilliance and scintillation.
Many jewelers recommend buying the best clarity grade you can afford. Since VS1 and VS2 are so close to flawless, you really can’t go wrong with either. It comes down to personal preference and budget. Evaluate the inclusions, listen to expert advice, and choose the diamond you find most beautiful. With proper care, your VS1 or VS2 diamond will provide a lifetime of beauty and sparkle.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I see inclusions in a VS1 or VS2 diamond?
Inclusions are not visible to the naked eye in VS1 or VS2 diamonds. Only under magnification can trained professionals spot the minuscule flaws. VS1 inclusions are extremely difficult to see, while VS2 have minor inclusions observable under 10x magnification. But both appear flawless without jewelry loupes or microscopes.
Which is better for engagement rings?
Both VS1 and VS2 are excellent choices for engagement rings. VS1 provides flawless optics for those special center stones, but you may sacrifice some size. VS2 allows you to maximize carat weight while still getting fabulous clarity. Consider the size and style of ring to decide what’s most important.
Are VS1 diamonds rare?
VS1 diamonds are more rare than lower clarity grades, but not as rare as internally flawless or VVS diamonds. About 4% of graded natural diamonds receive a VS1 clarity rating, so they fall into the “very rare” category. Their rarity contributes to the higher prices for VS1 diamonds.
Can I get a VS1 diamond discounted to VS2 prices?
Some retailers are willing to discount VS1 diamonds to match VS2 pricing if they have a hard time selling the stone. This allows savvy shoppers to potentially get a VS1 for the price of a VS2. However, diamond prices fluctuate so the difference is not always exactly 10-20%.
Should I buy online or in store?
You can find excellent values buying both VS1 and VS2 diamonds either online or in stores. Reputable local jewelers and online diamond sellers like Blue Nile, James Allen, and Brilliant Earth offer extensive inventories of VS1 and VS2 diamonds. Try both to compare quality and pricing.
Conclusion
VS1 and VS2 diamonds are both excellent choices that offer tremendous sparkle and fire. VS1 is the top preference for a flawless appearance, while VS2 gives you more size for your money. As long as you purchase from a respected dealer and inspect the diamond, you can’t go wrong with either clarity grade. Let your eye and budget guide you toward the ideal VS1 or VS2 diamond to adorn your jewelry.